Education committee backs move towards statutory consultation on future of Burravoe and Skeld schools
COUNCILLORS have taken a step closer to giving the go-ahead for a statutory consultation on the prospect of closing Burravoe Primary School in Yell, as well as the mothballed Skeld Primary School.
At a meeting on Monday morning members of Shetland Islands Council’s (SIC) education and families committee gave their backing to undertaking statutory consultations.
This means the committee is recommending to the full council to go ahead with approving consultations on possible closure when elected members meet on 9 December.
Options appraisals for the future of both schools have already been undertaken with input from the communities.
Reports on both schools, which came before the education and families committee, said statutory consultations on closure are the recommended way forward.
This is a different process than mothballing given that an outcome could be permanent closure.
Some councillors at Monday’s meeting pushed for the exploration of potential alternative uses for the Skeld school being carried out in tandem, but they were advised against this on legal grounds given the requirements of the statutory consultation process.
Shetland West member Liz Peterson said the community has raised possible future uses as a childcare/nursery setting or additional support needs (ASN) base.
However it was made clear at Monday’s meeting that potential future uses could only be looked once the school stops offering mainstream primary education.
The future of Burravoe in Yell has been looked at by SIC officers due to its falling school roll.
Four pupils are on the roll for the 2026/27 academic year, falling from 13 in 2017/18.
A report to councillors said current projections indicate that the school roll could drop to zero in 2027/28.
Skeld Primary School meanwhile was mothballed in 2024 due to its declining roll.
Reports to councillors said evidence was gathered through the options appraisal process for both schools, which considered assessment of alternatives, the likely educational impact, the possible effect on the community and travel arrangements.
Help keep Shetland’s news open to everyone
Good local journalism takes time, care and people on the ground. Membership helps us keep reporting the stories that matter to Shetland — and keep them free for everyone to read. Members get a weekly newsletter created especially for them, local ads only, and can bookmark stories and join the conversation in the comments.
The reports reiterated that progressing with a consultation would not itself “constitute a decision to permanently close” schools at this stage.
“Rather, it would provide an opportunity to further undertake a formal and transparent process through which pupils, parents and carers, staff, the local community, statutory consultees and other interested parties can express their views and provide further evidence in respect of a developed closure proposal paper before any permanent decision is taken,” they added.
At Wednesday’s meeting, chief education officer and manager for education and learning Fiona Robertson praised the consultation with the two communities during the options appraisal process.
But Peterson raised the Skeld community’s response to consultation exercises, saying a number of people want the school to reopen.
However councillors were told that no enrolment forms have been returned by parents in annual reviews since mothballing.
Peterson also claimed that possible future alternatives like ASN or childcare had been “discounted” by SIC officers.
But director of children’s services Samantha Flaws said there was nothing to say future uses could not be assessed – but that would only be possible once the school is closed.
Peterson also questioned if the SIC accepted that the impact on the Skeld community of the school being mothballed was “significantly greater” than anticipated.
Flaws responded to say that the committee’s main function relates to the provision of education, and said the mothballing decision back in 2024 was primarily around the challenges of a falling roll.
“I think sometimes it’s quite challenging to understand the impact of that in terms of the community, but the function of this committee is about the provision of education first and foremost,” she said.
During debate on Skeld, Peterson said she would “urge the council to take account of what the community is saying and listen to the community and try to find a forward with the community”.
Shetland Central member Moraig Lyall said as long as the building is mothballed it is an asset that costs money and offers no use, describing things as being in a “deadlock position” as a result.
But she suggested there could be future uses if the school closed, highlighting the example of a base for relief care.
Lerwick South councillor John Fraser was set to propose an amendment to instruct SIC officers to consider potential alternative uses of the building in tandem with a statutory consultation.
Governance director Kristen Johnson however said she would “really caution” against that given that it could put the statutory process at risk of being called in by government for “pre-empting a decision”.
This then saw Fraser remove his proposed amendment.
There were no questions about the Burravoe report, but Lyall said it is “clear that the threshold for beginning this process has been met”.
She highlighted that the majority of parents in the catchment area have already moved children to alternative schools.
Committee chair Davie Sandison said the “options that have been chosen are the only options really that are available at this stage”.
Lyall also said it was “unfortunate” that no councillors from the North Isles were at the meeting – a comment echoed by SIC convener Bryan Peterson.
Keep Shetland’s news open to everyone
Your membership helps us report the stories that matter to Shetland — and keep them free for everyone to read.














































































