Letters / Time for independence is not now

SNP Shetland convener Tom Wills (Hope over fear; SN, 20 January 2020) makes his case for independence and a second referendum. He claims the recent general election results provide a mandate.

First, the SNP lost the 2014 independence referendum by 55 per cent to 45 per cent.

Using Mr Wills’ own figures, the SNP received 45 per cent of the general election vote, exactly the same proportion as voted for independence in 2014. Apart from winning fewer seats this time than in 2015, not much appears to have changed, electorally. The 55 per cent who voted to remain in the UK are still, it seems, 55 per cent.

Obviously, there is no “mandate”.

Denouncing Westminster, he says: “While the UK has continued to run up debt, Scotland has lived within its budget …”

This is only true because Scotland is part of the UK. The situation will change, dramatically, with independence.


The Scottish Government receives a block grant from Westminster to cover its spending and isn’t allowed to borrow to supplement it. Therefore, we automatically “live within our budget”.

All borrowing is carried out by the UK government and contributes towards running the whole country, including the devolved governments’ grants.

At present, we are heavily subsidised since Scottish funding is independent of Scottish tax returns and increases automatically with UK government spending (Barnett Formula).

The more the UK spends, the more money Scotland receives and as we return less tax to the Exchequer than we receive in funding, the shortfall, our “notional budget deficit”, is funded by Westminster.

Scottish Government figures put our current deficit at £12.6 billion (including North Sea oil), equating to a £2,340 per annum subsidy for every man, woman and child in Scotland.

It follows that Mr Wills’ criticism of UK national debt is unfounded. We have received and spent our share of it.

Become a supporter of Shetland News


Nicola Sturgeon’s own Sustainable Growth Commission (SGC) acknowledges this, stating that an independent Scotland should pay the interest on our share of UK debt for the duration of its life, plus other fees for shared services, leading to an estimated Annual Solidarity Payment” of £5 billion per annum.

This payment calculation is convoluted and negotiable – there are ‘swings and roundabouts’ – so, for simplicity, assume the most favourable case i.e. no additional costs e.g. new currency/central bank, debt interest, capital investment or spending to stimulate the economy, etc.

Assumption: Initial independence budget deficit, £12.6 billion per annum, seven per cent of GDP.

The SNP intend to re-join the EU, whose joining conditions limit borrowing to 3 per cent of GDP (£5 billion per annum), meaning we would face £7.6 billion per annum of spending cuts/tax hikes, on an annual budget of £75 billion i.e. swingeing austerity!


Strathclyde University’s erudite Fraser of Allander Institute refer to this problem in their article entitled A referendum in 2020? noting: “Scotland would face a major challenge in meeting the EU target of a fiscal deficit no greater than 3 per cent of GDP.”

Joining the European Economic Area (EEA) instead of the EU won’t help. The SGC assert that current levels of budget deficit would be unsustainable, in any case, and recommend a 10-year programme to reduce it below 3 per cent GDP.

It follows that independence in our present economic circumstances would mean many years of austerity.

There may come a time for independence, once we know the truth about the effects of Brexit and our economy is no longer heavily subsidised by the UK. However, that time is not now.

John Tulloch

Become a supporter of Shetland News

Shetland News is asking its many readers to consider start paying for their dose of the latest local news delivered straight to their PC, tablet or mobile phone.

Journalism comes at a price and because that price is not being paid in today’s rapidly changing media world, most publishers - national and local - struggle financially despite very healthy audience figures.

Most online publishers have started charging for access to their websites, others have chosen a different route. Shetland News currently has  over 600 supporters  who are all making small voluntary financial contributions. All funds go towards covering our cost and improving the service further.

Your contribution will ensure Shetland News can: -

  • Bring you the headlines as they happen;
  • Stay editorially independent;
  • Give a voice to the community;
  • Grow site traffic further;
  • Research and publish more in-depth news, including more Shetland Lives features.

If you appreciate what we do and feel strongly about impartial local journalism, then please become a supporter of Shetland News by either making a single payment or monthly subscription.

Support us from as little as £3 per month – it only takes a minute to sign up. Thank you.



Subscribe to a selection of different newsletters from Shetland News, varying from breaking news delivered on the minute, to a weekly round-up of the opinion posts. All delivered straight to your inbox.

Daily Briefing Newsletter Weekly Highlights Newsletter Opinion Newsletter Life in Shetland Newsletter

JavaScript Required

We're sorry, but Shetland News isn't fully functional without JavaScript enabled.
Head over to the help page for instructions on how to enable JavaScript on your browser.

Your Privacy

We use cookies on our site to improve your experience.
By using our service, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy.

Browser is out-of-date

Shetland News isn't fully functional with this version of .
Head over to the help page for instructions on updating your browser for more security, improved speed and the best overall experience on this site.

Interested in Notifications?

Get notifications from Shetland News for important and breaking news.
You can unsubscribe at any time.

Become a supporter of Shetland News

We're committed to ensuring everyone has equitable access to impartial, open and quality local journalism that benefits all residents.

By supporting Shetland News, you play a vital role in ensuring we remain a pivotal resource in supporting the community.

Support us from as little as £3 per month – it only takes a minute to sign up. Thank you.