CAB - 7 Oct 2020 - 10 Oct 2020 - Advice

Council to foot the whole bill for new Scalloway fish market

Peterhead and Lerwick got into European fund first.

What the new Scalloway fish market should look like. Image: CHAP

SHETLAND Islands Council (SIC) will be forced to fund the entire £5.6 million cost of building the new Scalloway fish market after the scheme missed out on European funding.

Infrastructure services director John Smith confirmed today (Thursday) that the European Maritime and Fisheries Fund (EMFF) had rejected a bid for around half the cost of the scheme, as the pot had run out of money.

Smith said that EMFF funding for rebuilding Toft pier was also uncertain, as the matter had been deferred, but it could possibly come from the next round of fisheries fund awards.

A previous council decision was for Scalloway to go ahead even if the EMFF funding was not approved as it was deemed a “strategic” boost to the economy.

New director of infrastructure John Smith. Photo: SICInfrastructure Services director John Smith.

Smith said that there was no doubt fisheries developments would continue to be funded at Scalloway, a view reinforced by Scottish Secretary David Mundell’s announcement of a transitional fund for the industry on Monday.

Smith said: “The Scalloway market happened to be a project robust enough in its own content to allow things to go ahead anyway and it is absolutely a demonstration of the council’s commitment to the sector.”

The EMFF had considered the Scalloway fish market a “good” project, but the council – which runs Scalloway as well as most other ports and harbours in Shetland – had been beaten to the punch by the £51 million Peterhead harbour redevelopment and Lerwick Port Authority’s own new fish market, which had scooped most of the leftovers from the massive Peterhead bid.

“More critical to the business case for starting up the Scalloway market is the volume and value of landings being made into Scalloway. That represented a good business for the council and recognition from the council that this was a strategic decision to be made,” added Smith.

The SIC gets 2.5 per cent of the value of landings at Scalloway, and depending on the highly uncertain future for fisheries, the new fish market may be extended further if conditions require it.

Papers for a meeting of the harbour board on Monday say that money for the project will have to be borrowed and the financial implications of missing the Euro funding will be fleshed out in a report for the next cycle of meetings.

The report says: “The application for external funding was unsuccessful. The full project cost will therefore be funded by external borrowing. A report including detailed financial implications will be brought forward to the next cycle of meetings.”

Member of the harbour board, councillor Alastair Cooper said: “We are vexed that we did not get the funding. When you consider the amount of money that went into Peterhead, and that Lerwick got some of what was left, I am not surprised.

“But that said, we are doing pretty well and on the basis of how it is going, we can manage without that grant. A few years ago, if we had not got the grant, it would not have gone ahead. The value of the fish sold now is making a difference and that is because of the fortunes of the industry.”

Smith said that contractor for the new fish market CHAP Construction was examining the old structure prior to beginning demolition in the new year.

He added that the temporary fish market at Blacksness Pier was proving popular with its users and was a more than adequate short to medium term solution until the new market is complete sometime in 2020.

The harbour board report says that the EMFF grant review committee was supportive of the Toft Pier project in principal, as it benefited both fishing and aquaculture.

“However, it is unclear when or if any funding can be made available,” it said.

The tendering exercise has also been cancelled although tenders had already been received and evaluated.

“Planning and other consent applications will continue, and once the details of any external funding are made clear, a full business case will be presented to the council,” the report adds.