Carmichael says snap election gives voters chance to make feelings known on Brexit

Alistair Carmichael after winning re-election back in May 2015.

NORTHERN Isles MP Alistair Carmichael says Theresa May’s decision to call a snap election on 8 June will be an opportunity for those opposed to a “hard Brexit” to make their views known.

Speaking shortly after Tuesday morning’s surprise announcement, Carmichael urged voters who did not want to be taken out of the single market and the customs union to give their vote to his party, the Liberal Democrats.


Meanwhile local SNP convener Robbie McGregor said the party had immediately put a selection process for its candidate in place.

May’s decision to hold an election – having categorically ruled out holding a poll prior to 2020 in an interview last September – still needs to be ratified by the UK Parliament. 

If that happens, it will effectively mean Shetland Islands Council remains in pre-election purdah until the polls close on 8 June – meaning a slow start to council life for successful candidates in the local government elections on Thursday 4 May.


Carmichael said: “This is the opportunity for people who are not happy with Theresa May’s ‘hard Brexit’ taking us out of the single market, taking us away from the customs union, to make their views known.

“And the way you can do that is by lending your vote to the Liberal Democrats.”

Carmichael said he was “as surprised as everybody else” by the announcement.

He expects the SNP will be his strongest challengers. “I have never taken the result of any election for granted – and you’ve heard me say that many times over the years. With a majority of 817 I’m certainly not going to start now.”


The MP thinks May viewed her party’s lead over Labour as “too big a temptation to resist”, but is confident the Lib Dems will win seats back “across the whole of the UK” after some strong by-election results.

“Membership has virtually doubled, and in the 20 minutes following the announcement we recruited another 500 members,” he said. “The party has bounced back after a very difficult election in 2015.

“I actually don’t particularly think this is a necessary election, but it’s going to happen anyway, and it is probably the most important election – between Brexit and indyref2 – that I’ve known in my adult life.”

The SNP's Shetland convener - and soon-to-be SIC councillor - Robbie McGregor.

He accepted that, if Scotland elects a majority of pro-Yes MPs, it will “strengthen the hand of the SNP” in its demand for another Scottish independence referendum.

“If you are voting for the SNP, you will be voting for a second independence referendum – you can’t ignore that,” Carmichael added. 

Shetland voted to stay in the EU by 56.5 per cent to 43.5 per cent, although the fishing industry was strongly in favour of leaving in order to get out of the Common Fisheries Policy.

The MP, who said he would definitely be standing subject to gaining the local party’s approval, said he understood why fishermen saw the appeal in leaving the EU.


However, that view was “not a uniform one” in the wider industry – especially if the Bexit negotiations culminate in the UK leaving without a deal.

“I completely understand why the catching sector see this as an opportunity, and in many ways it is,” Carmichael said, “but for the processors and people who rely on selling their fish into the single market, the imposition of World Trade Organisation tariffs would not be good news.”

McGregor, who will become an SIC councillor next month, said he had been anticipating an election but thought it might not be until the summer. 

He said it would be an understatement to say the selection process would have to be accelerated with less than two months to go, and a candidate will be announced “sooner rather than later” once SNP members in Orkney and Shetland have had their say.

It will be the sixth time voters in Shetland have been asked to go to the polls since August 2014 following the Scottish independence referendum, UK and Scottish elections and the EU referendum.

“I thought there would be a snap election, but I didn’t expect it just as quickly as this,” McGregor said. “It’s at the behest of the Prime Minister to decide… our reaction is that we’re ready to fight an election at any time.”

He expects the election to be fought on various issues including Brexit and Scottish independence. “I would think it will be fought on both, and we’ll have to wait and see what happens.”

Conservative Party branch chairman for Shetland Maurice Mullay said he “very much” welcomed the announcement.

“The Scottish Conservatives are ready, organised, and optimistic. Only a vote for the Conservatives will ensure we get the strong leadership we need and to get the best Brexit deal for the whole country,” he said.
“And, only a vote for the Scottish Conservatives will send a strong message that we oppose SNP’s divisive plan for a second referendum and only the Scottish Conservatives have the strength to stand up for people who oppose the SNP’s plans.”


In May 2015, Carmichael was re-elected in the Northern Isles – a seat he has held since 2001 – with a much-reduced 41 per cent share of the vote. The SNP’s Danus Skene, who died last year, won 38 per cent.

Following the election, a legal challenge against the legitimacy of the result was heard at the Court of Session after it emerged that Carmichael had lied about his knowledge of a leaked memo relating to First Minister Nicola Sturgeon during the campaign.

Judges ruled that, while he had told a “blatant lie” about his knowledge of the memo on television, it had not been proved that he had committed an illegal practice.